DOLL THERAPY FOR ALZHEIMER’S DISEASE WAS ORIGINALLY PUBLISHED BY JOHN SCHMID ON MARCH 20, 2010
Eva Spreads Joy
I was speaking to my parents today, and my Mom went on about how much she loves her Doll (Luca). Her new name is Eva, my Mom’s second name. My Dad is totally amazed about the joy it is bringing my Mom. She takes it visiting in the community and lives to change her outfits. Eva is truly a blessing. Thank you so much. And, please thank the person who did such a beautiful job of creating such a wonderful doll that is so life like.
~ Elaine – Alberta, Canada
Research | Doll Therapy for Alzheimer’s
Much of the research involving doll therapy for Alzheimer’s disease has been carried out at Newcastle General Hospital in England and in care facilities in the area of Newcastle. Clinical Psychologist Ian James and nursing specialist Lorna Mackenzie, with others, reported significant improvement in the behavior of nursing home residents with dementia when dolls were introduced to the residents as a choice.
Various studies done by this group, all observing the effect of baby doll therapy on people with dementia, all reached similar conclusions. Using dolls to alter behavior in patients with dementia, Nursing Times VOL: 103, ISSUE: 5, PAGE NO: 36-37, (a British journal, which explains the funny spelling) summed it up like this:
The Ultimate in Doll Therapy for Alzheimer’s. Serenity Babies promise to take doll therapy to the next level. These extremely lifelike dolls are handmade by craftsmen using only the finest materials. Each doll is made individually, by hand, so every doll is unique.
The results of the study provide support for the hypotheses that after the introduction of dolls, doll-users showed an increase in positive behaviour and a decrease in negative behaviour and incidents of aggression compared with before the dolls were introduced. These results support previous attitudinal studies, which have reported doll therapy to be an effective approach in reducing negative and challenging behaviours, and promoting more positive behaviours and mood.
These conclusions are in agreement with so much anecdotal evidence reported by caregivers that credit doll therapy for Alzheimer’s with increasing quality of life for people with dementia. Some have even reported that they were able to reduce medications as a direct result of doll therapy.
Doll therapy for Alzheimer’s? It is important that carers be onboard…
A study³ published in the journal Age and Ageing concentrated, in part, on caregiver reaction to the introduction of dolls into the care environment. Residents with dementia in two facilities in England were introduced to dolls. All of the caregivers in the facility were given surveys before and after the study.
Although nine of the 46 staff members voiced some initial concern, mostly centering on the idea that the dolls would be ‘babyish’, ‘ totally demeaning’, ‘ patronizing’, or otherwise ‘inappropriate’. In the interview that followed the conclusion of the study, only one caregiver retained this concern. All of the others “felt that there were clear benefits of using the dolls. . . . 14 carers felt that residents’ lives were a little better, and 32 felt that their lives were much better. Strong testimony that doll therapy for Alzheimer’s and other dementia really helps.
Doll Therapy for Alzheimer’s — Not for Everyone
Ivy sucking her little thumb
The nurturing instinct is strong. This instinct is a big part of the reason that doll therapy is so effective. On the other hand, it can lead to some problems that should be watched for when introducing dolls as therapy. In community settings, ownership issues have led to arguments between residents. Anxiety can result from dolls being mislaid. Redirecting attention until the lost doll is found will usually defuse this potential calamity.
Family members of caregivers sometimes see the use of dolls as demeaning. From the study in Age and Aging cited above:
A question concerning the carers’ ‘initial impression of the use of dolls when they first heard about them’ had intended to capture staff’s misgivings. Three staff reported major concerns, six had minor concerns, 16 were neutral, six were mildly positive and 15 were very positive from the outset. .. 13% of carers recorded that they had misgivings—carer quotes included: ‘Thought it was babyish’; ‘. . . totally demeaning’; ‘. . . patronising’; ‘inappropriate . . ., thought it would confuse residents further..
These concerns can be even more pronounced when trying to convince family care partners that their loved one might benefit from a doll. Another study² reported, “there had been some problems using the dolls, such as arguments between residents over ownership of dolls, residents trying to feed their dolls, and dolls being mislaid leading to distress. In addition, some staff working in homes felt that the dolls may be infantilising residents.”
but having seen the way residents react when using the doll opinion has changed’.
Other considerations: “Despite these positive findings,
* We should repeat here that doll therapy is not for everyone. If you see that it is more problematic than beneficial, discontinue it in favor of some alternate non-pharmacological therapy.
Guidelines for Doll Therapy For Alzheimer’s Disease
Doll therapy (also known as baby doll therapy) is not for everyone. More women than men will choose a doll to nurture, but some men do benefit greatly from holding a doll, so don’t rule out doll therapy for the man or men in your care. Another option to the doll is a Teddy Bear or other stuffed animal. We have a selection of bears and other animals that provide aromatherapy and heat and cold therapy as well as the therapy provided by the act of nurturing. Our best-selling Twiddle Pup and Twiddle Cats, in certain cases, would even qualify for doll therapy.
Providing doll therapy for Alzheimer’s disease
-
Coco is enjoying the sunny morning.
Read more about these incredibly lifelike Serenity Babies.Choose a doll that is lifelike. One that looks like a real baby, is 15 – 20 inches long, and weighs 3 – 6 pounds will get a much better response and result than one that is smaller or unrealistic looking, or one that looks like an older child. This is not to say that other dolls can’t be effective, but our recommendation is evidence based¹.
- We recommend a doll that represents an age from newborn to a year or so in age. Dolls that look like toddlers may work for some, but most people with dementia will connect better with a younger looking doll.
- Do not hand a person a doll – people don’t like responsibility imposed upon them. Place the doll where it can be discovered, or hold it yourself. Allow the individual to choose the responsibility of caring for the baby.
- Some people with dementia will think that the doll is a real baby. Others will know that it is just a doll, but love it just the same. Some will think it is alive one day, and know it is a doll the next. Be careful how you refer to the doll. If it has a name, refer to it by that name.
- There are potential drawbacks to doll therapy. It is not for everyone with dementia. Until a bond is created between the individual and his or her doll, be alert to behaviors that may indicate that a connection will likely not happen. There are other therapies and activities that may suit that person better.
Introducing the therapy doll
[pullquote]He’s a different man with a doll in his hand. I found out more about him—the tender side.
~ Caregiver[/pullquote]It is important that a doll not be given directly to the person with Alzheimer’s disease. Rather it should be left somewhere, on a table or sitting in a chair, for example, somewhere that she will easily find it. This way the individual can make the choice to provide care for the doll, not feel that they are being given the responsibility to do so, which could cause anxiety or result in the doll being rejected.
For Doll Therapy to be effective, it is recommended that you use a doll that is as lifelike as possible. Introduce the doll in the middle stages of Alzheimer’s, or even in an earlier stage, depending on the individual. Often when introduced later, the person fails to or has a more difficult time making a connection with the doll. Once the connection has been made, the rest is easy. It’s a self-administering therapy
Related Research
Doll Therapy for Alzheimer’s
- Baby dolls as therapeutic tools for severe dementia patients; (2001).T. Tamura, K. Nakajima, M. Nambu, K. Nakamura, S. Yonemitsu, A. Itoh, Y. Higashi, T. Fujimoto, H. Uno; Gerontechnology Vol 1, No 2 (2001)
- Using dolls to alter behaviour in patients with dementia: (2007). Jenny Ellingford, BSc,; Ian James, PhD, MSc, BSc, C.Psychol; Lorna Mackenzie, RMN; Lisa Marsland, BSc, MSc. University.VOL: 103, ISSUE: 5, PAGE NO: 36-37
- A pilot study on the use of dolls for people with dementia; Lorna Mackenzie Ian Andrew James Rachel Morse Elizabeta Mukaetova-LadinskaF. Katharina Reichelt. Age and Ageing, Volume 35, Issue 4, 1 July 2006, Pages 441–444.
Related Research: Doll Therapy for Alzheimer’s
A study¹ reported in the Journal of Gerontechnology in 2001 actually used one of the Cuddle Baby dolls (pictured above). The study reported on the effects that dolls had on a group of people in a long-term care facility in Japan, most whom had dementia, and all who suffered from Sundowners syndrome. For the most part the dolls influenced behavior in a significant way; behavior classified as: “no reaction, close observation (of the doll), care giving, and communication with other patients.” There was a small group that seemed to be completely uninterested in the dolls, which reinforces our point that doll therapy is not for everyone.
The researchers described the affect caring for a doll had on one subject of the study:
We monitored the activities of an individual patient with and without intervention with (a doll). She took extensive care of the baby doll during the intervention period. However, in the absence of the doll, she became agitated and tended to wander around, while during doll intervention she was calm and gentle.
The study reinforces what we know, that for many people with dementia, doll therapy is a meaningful and effective intervention. A bonus is their finding that more realistic looking and feeling dolls were significantly better at soliciting positive responses, and our Cuddle Baby performed the best of three dolls used in the study!
5 comment(s) need to be approved.
Trackbacks & Pingbacks
-
[…] The above quotation is a note of thanks from a friend in Australia who found that her mother was greatly comforted by the simple act of caring for a doll. Most of the evidence supporting doll therapy as an effective alternative therapy for Alzheimer’s disease is anecdotal, like Kate’s testimony, but there is quite a lot of it. As is often the case, so much anecdotal evidence usually gets the pro’s interested. A growing body of medical and scientific work supports what so many social workers, nurses, and caregivers have known for a long time; doll therapy works as a way to treat many of the behavioral symptoms of Alzheimer’s disease and other types of dementia. Read more…. […]
-
[…] If you have ever experienced caring for a loved one who suffers from dementia, you are well aware of how difficult it is to find solutions that could ameliorate the disease’s troublesome effects. Caregivers of dementia patients in nursing home facilities often struggle with this issue, as well. Fortunately, a recent study has revealed that dolls can play a significant role in dementia intervention for patients in nursing homes. Through the therapeutic use of dolls, fifty-one nursing home resident participants with dementia showed substantial improvements in their mood, behaviors, and social interactions. More specifically, patient aggressive and obsessive behaviors, wandering, unfavorable verbalization, negative mood, and negative physical appearance improved significantly. […]
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!
Leave a Reply
Organizations & Affiliations
Purple Angel Ambassador
Dementia Friendly America
It got me when you said that there has been anecdotal evidence wherein people with Alzheimer’s disease have an increase in their quality of life when given doll therapy services. My grandmother is still fine regarding her mental health, but she would definitely love it if I get her vintage dolls for sale. It will be a dual-purpose item if I give her one, because she can use it to entertain herself while, possibly, preventing the start of memory issues.
A vintage doll will likely not work well as a therapy doll. Choose a doll that resembles a newborn for the best results. If she is not demonstrating signs of dementia then a doll like this might please her. Don’t, however, count on it preventing memory issues. The goal of doll therapy is to improve quality of life.
I wonder if you have heard of (WBV ) whole body vibration. The science is very promising for many conditions, such as osteoarthritis, decreasing cortisol levels, increasing HGH . I was just wondering if their are any studies if it can effect Alzheimer’s disease?
I have not, Joe. Something I will look into. Perhaps our readers can help out with this one.
Your blog has provided useful information for the work. All the tips in the post are great. Thanks for sharing. keep blogging~!
카지노사이트
Dear John,
Gorgeous dolls! Unfortunately you have forgotten about all us Canadians! I just tried to order one of your dolls and did not find Canada on the list for shipping estimates. Not to worry as I am afraid with the original price of the doll, the exchange rate, and the shipping charge would way over budget for any senior. Glad you are doing the work you are doing to help the elderly…. but ….if my opinion counts, you may want to try to lower your prices if you are sincerely trying to help seniors, who in this country have a monthly government income of approx. $1500 dollars (CDN) while some are living in long term care facilities costing $2500.00 to $5000.00 monthly….thank you and keep up the great work on helping those of us who have parents with Dementia!
Hi Catherine,
Thank you for your comment and your suggestions.
We have not forgotten about our neighbors to the north. Unfortunately, we are experiencing some software issues that don’t allow our store to calculate an accurate shipping cost to Canada. We are accepting phone orders from Canadian customers at our toll free number – 877/300.3021. We are working on the programming and we hope to be able to make our online ordering process available to Canada very soon.
Yes, our expensive dolls are very expensive. They’re handmade and take many hours to complete. We do have therapy dolls in a wide range of prices. You can see all or our dolls at https://store.best-alzheimers-products.com/alzheimers-alternative-therapy/dolls-for-dementia.html. All of our dolls are realistic; of course, the higher the price, the better the realism. There is evidence that the more life-like dolls get a better response and are more therapeutic. And we have a broad range of prices on other products as well, from just a few dollars to the Serenity Baby dolls.
would love to introduce this to homes in my area. going to get my mom involved first, she has dementia. is there a toolkit to take this into senior homes
Have you known the dolls to be used for a younger woman with an intellectual disability who has not experienced motherhood?
This is a very interesting question, Faye, and I don’t have a good answer for you. Nurturing does seem to be an instinct that is present in all of us, men and women, to one degree or another. I would guess it is generally stronger in women than in men, and strengthened in anyone who has raised children. There is a good chance that this woman will take to doll therapy and get some comfort from it, but I haven’t seen any research or reports that address this issue. Does this woman respond to pets? children? or even stuffed animals? These might be indicators of how well she would accept a doll. I suggest you borrow a doll and see how she reacts to it. Don’t give it to her, but leave it somewhere that she will find it. Her reaction to it should tell you what you need to know. Meantime, I am going to look for others who might have some experience in this.
Thanks for that reply. Just to clarify, this young lady loves babies and animals very much but she has not shown any interest in regular dolls, teddy bears or stuffed animals. We will start as you suggest and leave a realistic looking doll around and see what she does.
I work with Dementia patients and the Doll Therapy does very often work, I think it sometimes depends on how advanced the Dementia is
You’re right, Joan. Like almost everything else we talk about and recommend, how well it works depends on so many factors. Personality, stage, personal interests and history, etc. But when doll therapy works, it really works!
I’m from the UK and “behaviour” is our way of spelling it 🙂 No idea where “behavior” came from, but it being British doesn’t explain it!
I would love to actually learn how to do doll therapy, Can you point me in the right direction? I really love this idea
Thanks
Hi Tassie – Doll therapy is different from some of the other alternative therapies that we discuss. Music and art therapies have curricula and special schools where the disciplines are taught.There are even certifications and degrees. It’s not the same with doll therapy, partly because doll therapy is relatively easy. We call it a self-administering therapy. If a person responds well to the introduction of a doll, all that is necessary is that you make a doll available. That’s pretty much it.The individual’s nurturing instincts take over – and that’s the therapy. It can be an amazing thing to see, however.
Can you please let me know where I can purchase the Dolls from.
Thank you!
Jane
Hi Jane,
All of our dolls are available at our online store: https://store.best-alzheimers-products.com/alzheimers-alternative-therapy/doll-therapy.html (or Click Here) or by phone. If you are interested in one of the Serenity Babies (the $800 dolls), please call – 877.300.3021. These are all custom made to your order, and we need quite a bit of information from you to make sure the doll is just as you want it.